• Super Lawyers
  • Lexis Nexis
  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum

ambulanceNot all traffic accidents are caused by obvious wrongdoers, such as drunk drivers or texting teenagers. Sometimes, an Ohio car accident is caused by someone who would otherwise be the “good guy” – like the ambulance driver who allegedly caused the serious crash that gave rise to litigation described in more detail below.

When the allegedly at-fault person is a government employee, special rules may apply. Under the doctrine known as sovereign immunity, the government may only be sued when it has expressly consented to be sued, so it is important to talk to an attorney as soon as possible if you have been hurt in  an accident caused by a government vehicle. This is even more the case when the at fault vehicle is a safety vehicle like an ambulance or police car. In that case, even more restrictive rules may apply.

Facts of the Case

motorcycle riderSeeking fair compensation for injuries suffered in an Ohio motorcycle accident can be both complicated and time-consuming.  Motorcycle and vehicle accident lawsuits usually proceed on a a  negligence theory in which a plaintiff must prove that a defendant ( the responsible party) owed a duty to the plaintiff ( the injured party bringing the lawsuit), that the defendant breached that duty and that as a direct or proximate result of that negligence,  the plaintiff suffered injuries and damages. The plaintiff must show  that there was a link between the plaintiff’s damages and the defendant’s breach of duty in order topursue monetary payment for his or her losses in the accident.

In some cases, the defendant may have an affirmative defense that defeats the plaintiff’s claim, and some defendants – such as governmental entities – may be immune from suit because they are a government entity . This is known as sovereign immunity.

Facts of the Case

Department of TransportationCleveland car accidents can range in complexity from one driver suing another for simple negligence to a much more complicated case involving multiple parties and multiple theories of liability ( reasons why an Ohio driver might be at fault).

For example, if the victim of  an accident was on the job at the time, this might lead to a workers’ compensation claim for the injured driver as well as  a claim against the other driver’s  employer for what is known as  vicarious liability. If there was a chain collision, several drivers may be sued for failing to maintain an adequate lookout, or speeding, for example, and failing to stop in time to avoid the collision. Sometimes,  especially if there is a dispute regarding coverage or if there are multiple insurance companies covering one or more of the vehicles involved in the crash, or a dispute over coverage, the various parties’ insurance carriers may also be brought into the litigation .

Facts of the Case

street crossing

People who are involved in an Ohio car accident sometimes mistakenly think that hiring an attorney as soon as possible after the collision is unnecessary because, after all, “the law is the law,” and any issues that might arise can be handled later just as easily as sooner.

But no two cases are exactly alike and in fact, any car accident case may raise complex insurance or other issues, the analysis of which may determine whether the injured party gets the compensation they deserve.. With this in mind, it is easy to see why retaining an experienced personal injury attorney who can help investigate the cause of an accident, identify potential witnesses, gather important medical records and proof of injury, and deal directly with insurance adjusters who will take them seriously can be very important.

Facts of the Case

In a case recently decided in Cleveland, Ohio by the Eighth Appellate District (Cuyahoga County), the plaintiff was a woman hit by a car in July 2015 while crossing the road. She was seriously injured, incurring over $250,000 in medical bills. At the time of the accident, the woman’s son and his family were living in her home while their new home was being built. They had moved into the plaintiff’s home about five weeks prior to her accident, and they moved out about two months after the accident.

Continue reading

Unfortunately, car accidents happen for many reasons.  Drivers may be distracted.  Bad weather can make visibility difficult and stopping even harder.  Perhaps the other car ran a red light and struck you.  Another, less frequent cause for car collisions is what Ohio law calls a “sudden medical emergency.”  It’s important to know what is (and is not) a sudden medical emergency (“SME”) because the condition may excuse the driver who suffered one from paying for injuries or damages he or she caused.

Ohio first recognized “sudden medical emergency” as an excuse (or legal defense) for automotive negligence in 1956.  In Lehman v. Haynam, the Ohio Supreme Court described SME as an instance, “where the driver of an automobile is suddenly stricken by a period of unconsciousness which he had no reason to anticipate and which renders it impossible for him to control the car he is driving. . . .”  But does this mean that a driver who fell asleep behind the wheel and hit you is not liable for injuries he/she caused?  No, not at all.  Continue reading

Bicycle riding is a wonderful sport.  I ride between 2-3,000 miles per year, often commuting the 13 miles from my home to the law offices of Rubin Guttman & Associates.  Bicycle riding on our city streets always calls for great care and following the big three Rules of the Road: 1) Be careful; 2) Be lawful (obey the traffic laws); and 3) Be well lit (use lights on the front of your bike, on the back of your bike, and on your helmet).

These rules apply all year, but are even more important during the winter months when, according to Bikewinter.org  whose slogan is “Every day is a Great day to ride a bike,” you’ve got to make a special effort to know your hazards.  Avoid streets with chuckholes to the extent possible, ride carefully and predictably and remember, under Ohio law, you have all the rights and responsibilities of a motor vehicle.  Bicycle riders have a right to the road.  Check out the Ohio Department of Transportation’s Cycling Smarter Guide for the whole legal picture. Bikeradar.com, a British and American bike riding  site cautions against black ice on winter roads, something we know all to much about in Cleveland and Northern Ohio.  Apply your brakes equally and in a measured way. Take it easy and don’t focus on speed in the winter.

Continue reading

Insuring your car may feel expensive.  As a car owner, you must buy  liability coverage (if you strike another’s car).  You can also select coverages to pay for repairs to your car, to cover towing charges, for medical expenses, and even the costs of a temporary rental car.  A handy buying guide, “Insurance 101,” is available from the Ohio Department of Insurance.  Ohio law requires that each driver carry minimum liability coverage of $25,000 per person; $50,000 per accident (25/50).  But with all the choices and charges, you may be confused about whether to purchase uninsured motorist or underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverages too.

From our perspective, the answer is a strong “YES”.  Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage protects you and others in your car when another driver injures you but their insurance is insufficient to compensate you for your injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, and other losses.  Continue reading

There’s no doubt that distracted driving is responsible for many car accidents.  Everything from texting, changing the entertainment source on the car radio, trying to calm a frazzled toddler, or even enjoying a sip of that drink from the drive-through lane can take a driver’s attention from where it belongs — on surrounding traffic and safely operating a car.  AAA’s Foundation for Traffic Safety suggests that each year 5,000 fatal car crashes can be attributed to driver distraction.

Now it seems that automobile insurance giant, Allstate, wants to peak over your shoulder and into your car to see whether you are driving while distracted.  And Allstate isn’t watching just because you have insurance with that company, Allstate may be tracking your driving behavior from sensors on the vehicle next to you or behind you in traffic.  Continue reading

As a Social Security disability attorney with Rubin Guttman & Associates, I sometimes hear frustrated clients report that a neighbor, a distant relative, or an acquaintance is collecting disability benefits from a phony claim.  Maybe the “disabled” person claims serious back injuries and chronic pain but is seen doing heavy yard work.  Other times I hear about people who are addicts or just unwilling to work like the rest of us.  Still other supposedly disabled individuals are described as double dipping  —  they collect disability benefits while working nearly full time or under the table!  The underlying feeling is, “it’s just not fair.”  And our clients are right, it’s not fair for a person who is not entitled to Social Security disability benefits to defraud the government and collect benefits.  Help may be on the way.

According to an October article in The Fiscal Times, Congress is moving forward to enact laws which will crack down on Social Security disability fraud.  The new laws include strong criminal and civil penalties for violators.  The proposed laws could impact the roughly 11 million disabled beneficiaries of the Social Security disability program.  Continue reading